Door or seals in a rental property

Looking for honest renter advice here: my bedroom opens to a lively hallway, and the current door is clearly hollow—voices and footsteps slide right through the cracks. I can’t rebuild walls, but I might be able to either add proper perimeter seals with an automatic drop seal or (if the super agrees) swap the slab for a solid-core leaf. Has anyone compared both in a rental? Did seals alone get you most of the way, or did the mass upgrade feel like night-and-day? Bonus points for tips about keeping it “reversible” and not annoying the landlord.
alikaka 1 day, 18 hours ago in Home and Garden
1 Answer(s)
I literally did this swap last month. Started cheap: adhesive perimeter gasketing and an automatic drop seal under the door—big leap for speech leaking from the corridor. Later I replaced the hollow-core with a solid-core slab and that tightened the low/mid frequencies even more, but only after I tuned the latch side and threshold so there were no gaps. Also check the frame: tighten hinge screws into the stud and add a sweep or threshold if needed. If you want a quick sanity check, I got a friendly walkthrough from New York Soundproofing—they explained why mass + airtightness beats either alone and helped me phrase a simple ask for my landlord. If approval’s tricky, try seals first; if you can change the leaf, do both for the best result.
toxatyt 1 day, 16 hours ago